Virtual Library of Newspaper Articles


A First Look at Karla

An exclusive review of the contentious film

By Matthew Hays, August 12, 2005

Looks are deceiving: Misha Collins as Paul Bernardo and and Laura Prepon as Karla Homolka in Karla. Courtesy Quantum Entertainment.

Looks are deceiving: Misha Collins as Paul Bernardo and and Laura Prepon as Karla Homolka in Karla. Courtesy Quantum Entertainment.

Not many films have created as much of a furor in Canada as Karla. Nice, polite Canadians reacted with abject horror when it was announced last year that a Los Angeles-based film company had a movie about Karla Homolka in the works. Later, as questions about the films distribution surfaced, Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty urged Ontarians to boycott it. The project, it was assumed by many from the get-go, could amount to nothing but sheer exploitation in pursuit of profit.

It didnt help that director Joel Benders filmography includes such titles as Jennifer is Dead and Gas Pump Girls. Media reports also noted that the actors cast as serial killers Homolka and husband Paul Bernardo were Laura Prepon (That 70s Show) and Misha Collins, performers associated with the medium of television as if this distinction somehow made them inherently bottom-drawer. The filmmakers announced that the title of the film had been changed from Deadly to Karla, in an apparent bid for greater sensitivity.

Then came the late-July announcement that Montreals World Film Festival had invited Karla to screen as part of its annual event. Apparently unaware of the level of discomfort much of English Canada had with the films subject matter, festival founder and director Serge Losique insisted that Karla had enough artistic merit to warrant a screening. By early August, however, Losique announced that Karla would be withdrawn from the World Film Festival, publicly acknowledging that he was doing so as a direct result of pressure from one of his key corporate sponsors, Air Canada.

Even if Karla was the most exploitative, sleazy film in history, the move by the World Film Festival undoubtedly sets a precarious precedent: this is the first time a Canadian film festival has yanked a movie while publicly citing corporate-sponsor pressure as the reason for doing so. Film festivals have long been sacred points of distribution for filmmakers, thought to be bastions of integrity where taboo or unpopular subjects could be broached without fear of censorship. Do we really want Air Canada or any corporate sponsor deciding what films we get to see? Losique seemed to think Karla was worth screening and defending when he initially announced its premiere at his festival. Losique even alluded to the horrors depicted by Shakespeare in his defence of the film but when Air Canada threatened to bolt, all mention of the Bard was dropped. One may think that Karla is simply inconsequential garbage, but some of the most intriguing films of recent years have been accompanied by controversy, including Capturing the Friedmans, The Passion of the Christ and Fahrenheit 9/11. Indeed, the term slippery slope does spring to mind.

Though no fan of censorship of any kind, while watching Karla, I could see why the film will incense some Canadian audiences. On its surface, it is a very straightforward accounting of the relationship between Homolka and Bernardo presented here in their Technicolor contrasts: a seemingly simple, ordinary, banal, Southern Ontario couple implicated in rape and killing. True to contemporary filmmaking styles, many of the scenes between the two and their victims are very uncomfortable to watch. The filmmakers have repeatedly told the press they wanted to avoid being too explicit, but in a post-Hitchcock world, audience expectations demand that we see sequences that resemble the Real Thing. Frankly, it is impossible to imagine someone creating a cinematic treatment of this particular story without delving into the lurid for much of the film. We are spared some things: though there is a kiss between Homolka and one of their victims (the victims names have all been changed) there is no actual visualization of rape that much, at least, is left to our imaginations.

The ugly truth: Prepon as Karla. Courtesy Quantum Entertainment.
The ugly truth: Prepon as Karla. Courtesy Quantum Entertainment.

Explicit sex and violence aside, it is Karlas perspective that may upset viewers still reeling from the horrors of the Bernardo-Homolka crimes. Obviously, much of the reason Karla has met with calls for boycotts and censorship is because of timing: the film was completed within weeks of Homolkas release from prison earlier this summer, a release many people feel was premature, given the extent of her involvement in the sexual violations and deaths of several women (including teenaged girls, one of whom was her sister). A superficial reading of the film indicates that Homolka was the victim of a misogynistic, serial-raping and -killing husband, a battered wife who could not escape the clutches of her violent, wildly manipulative mate, a woman so engulfed in fear that she was somehow forced into complicity with his crimes. At one point, an abducted victim has a moment alone with Homolka, who was just hit by Bernardo before he left the room. Why do you stay? she sobs to Homolka, who responds simply, You dont understand.

But Karla subtly throws Homolkas line of reasoning into question in two key ways. The entire film is told in flashback; Homolka describes to a psychiatrist how she met Bernardo and what happened over the years. The psychiatric-interview-as-screenwriting-device is at times a bit clunky, but its intent is clear: to indicate to the audience that Homolka is an unreliable narrator. As well, in her portrayal of Homolka, Laura Prepon delivers a performance so measured and intelligent that it forces us to continually question Homolkas credibility as a victim.

Standing trial: Prepon testifies in Karla. Courtesy Quantum Entertainment.
Standing trial: Prepon testifies in Karla. Courtesy Quantum Entertainment.

Clearly, exploitation is in the eye of the beholder, but Karla has merits that make it something other than just utter sleaze. Despite a limited budget, it is well shot and is buoyed by a solid cast, especially its two leads. Indeed, Canadas collective psyche may not be ready for widespread distribution of Karla, but if people remain so troubled by this now-famous bit of crime and punishment, we can always exercise our democratic right to stay home and do something else with our time.

Though only a handful of Canadians have actually seen Karla, this movie has already ignited a phenomenon in our country. In particular, it has exposed the hypocrisy of much of the media, who have admonished the filmmakers behind Karla for exploiting this piece of true crime while pumping up their own ratings and newspaper sales by languishing in an orgy of Homolka-driven headlines and stories a move that has allowed them to be at once prurient and puritanical.

As horrid as this story may be, it is inarguable that many great filmmakers have made films about murderers that were based on true stories Hitchcock (Psycho), Scorsese (Taxi Driver), Tobe Hooper (The Texas Chainsaw Massacre), Jonathan Demme (Silence of the Lambs), among others. Many are now regarded as important, groundbreaking cinematic art. Some, such as Spike Lees Summer of Sam, were released despite the protests of victims families. My verdict is that Karla is neither a masterpiece nor a disaster. It has its strong moments, but feels much like a better-than-average movie-of-the-week (though perhaps a bit too extreme for the mainstream TV networks). Those opposed to Karla none of whom, it must be noted, have actually seen it will probably succeed in blocking its screening at a Canadian film festival or at any of the nations cinemas. But in what is arguably the most potent irony of the controversy, they have now piqued everyones curiosity about this forbidden film, ensuring that given Internet mail-order service and the popularity of the DVD format Karla will almost certainly find a significant audience.

Matthew Hays is a Montreal writer.

Our Most Popular Web Page

Sex Offenders
Female Sexual Predators

Hundreds of them.... female teachers who sexually assaulted 12 year old boys. Read about a lesbian tennis coach who sexually assaulted her 13 year old female student.

Read how a 40 year old female sexual predator blamed a 7 year old boy whom she claimed was "coming on to me" and whom she "hoped to marry someday."  Read More ..

The Guardian UK - Female Sexual Predators - Female sex offenders

Up to 64,000 women in UK 'are child-sex offenders'

After Plymouth case shocked the nation, police say number of women abusing children

The Guardian UK and The Observer
4 October 2009

Researchers from the Lucy Faithfull Foundation (LFF), a child protection charity that deals with British female sex offenders, said its studies confirmed that a "fair proportion" of child abusers were women. Donald Findlater, director of research and development, said results indicated that up to 20% of a conservative estimate of 320,000 suspected UK paedophiles were women.

Female Teacher Sexual Assault Student

Associated Press logo

Female Teacher Charged With Sex Assault on Seventh-Grade Boy

Associated Press / Fox News

MORRISTOWN, N.J. — A 35-year-old seventh-grade teacher was charged with having sex with one of her students at least 20 times at the teacher's home.

Jodi Thorp, 35, surrendered to authorities Monday on charges of aggravated sexual assault, aggravated sexual contact and endangering the welfare of a child. Prosecutors claim she had sex with the boy at her Mendham home between June 2001 and September 2002. The boy is now 15.

The Guardian newspaper logo

Female Teacher jailed for sex with boy

The Guardian, UK
August 16, 2005

A married primary schoolteacher was jailed for 15 months yesterday after admitting having sex with an underage teenage boy.

Hannah Grice, 32, pleaded guilty at an earlier hearing to two counts of indecent assault on the boy, who was aged 14 and 15 at the time of the offences.

Sentencing her at Stafford crown court, Judge John Shand told Grice, from Cannock, Staffordshire, she had abused her position of trust.

"Cases such as this are, of course, made worse by the fact that you were a member of the teaching profession," he told her. "You should have been very sensitive indeed to child welfare issues." Grice was also ordered to register as a sex offender for 10 years. Read More ..

Female Sexual Predators / Female Sex Offenders

Vancouver Sun

3 in 4 B.C. boys on street sexually exploited by women

VANCOUVER - Canada's largest study into the sexual exploitation of street kids and runaways has shattered some myths about who the abusers might be - with the most surprising finding being that many are women seeking sex with young males.

"Some youth in each gender were exploited by women with more than three out of four (79 per cent) sexually exploited males reporting exchanging sex for money or goods with a female," said Elizabeth Saewyc, associate professor of nursing at the University of British Columbia and principal investigator for the study conducted by Vancouver's McCreary Centre Society.

"I must admit it wasn't something we were expecting."

Associated Press

Mom drugged daughter to get her pregnant: police

Associate Press, U.S.A.
April 3, 2009

PITTSBURGH (AP) - A western Pennsylvania mother has been charged with giving her 13-year-old daughter drugs and alcohol so the woman's boyfriend could impregnate the girl without her knowing, police said Thursday.

Shana Brown, 32, is no longer able to have children but wanted to have a baby with her current boyfriend, Duane Calloway, said Uniontown Police Detective Donald Gmitter. The pair decided to drug the girl so Calloway, 40, could have sex with her, he added.

"There's some sick people on this case," Gmitter said.

Brown has been charged with endangering the welfare of a child, turned herself in Thursday and was being held in the Fayette County jail, police said. Brown's attorney did not return a call for comment.

Calloway faces several counts of attempted rape. He was arrested Wednesday and remains in jail. It was not immediately clear whether he had an attorney.

The three attacks occurred in Brown's home in Uniontown, about 50 miles south of Pittsburgh, according to the criminal complaint.

Female Sexual Predators / Female Sex Offenders

The Oprah Winfrey Show

Lisa Ling Video Interview of Female Sexual Predator / Offender

This woman raped or sexually assaulted over 100 children by her own account.

Research - 20% out of 800 Sex Offenders are Female

Guardian UK

Our blind rage at women who abuse

Because we assume women never commit child sexual abuse, we treat one who is accused with disproportionate disgust

The Guardian, UK
June 11, 2009

About 20 years ago, I gave a talk about sexual abuse to the RAF. At the end, a young airman came up to me and said, "It's not just men, you know," before hurriedly walking away. That pulled me up sharp. Up till then, like most people working in the area of sexual abuse, I'd always assumed the abusers were men.

This just isn't so. We can't be sure of the precise prevalence of sexual abuse by women, as there hasn't been enough research into the subject. Academics have just assumed it doesn't happened. But conservative estimates suggest that 5% of girls and 20% of boys who have reported being abused have been abused by women. From my own research - I have had 800 cases reported to me - I believe the more likely figure is that it is 20% of all sexual abuse that is done by women.

It is women themselves who have done most to propagate this conspiracy of silence. It has almost become a feminist axiom that it is men who are to blame for abuse and that if women are in some way implicated, it is only because they have somehow been forced or controlled into doing so against their will. Again, this turns out to be completely incorrect: 75% of the cases reported to me involved women acting on their own.  Read More ..

Why you shouldn't see VAGINA MONOLOGUES

Lesbian Pedophilia and the rape of girls

Don't attend performances.

Mother had sex with child sons | Toronto Star

Mother confesses to sex with sons

Had intercourse with 2 teenagers

Pleads guilty to incest charges

A Kitchener woman has pleaded guilty to having sexual intercourse with her two teenage sons on separate occasions.

Mainichi Daily News| Woman who cut off her newborn son's genitals handed 5-year prison term

Woman who cut off her newborn son's private parts handed 5-year prison term

Mainichi Daily News, Sakai, Osaka, Japan, November 26, 2006

SAKAI, Osaka -- A woman accused of cutting off her newborn son's private parts in 2004 was ordered Monday to spend five years behind bars.

The Sakai branch of the Osaka District Court convicted Shizue Tamura, 27, a resident of Izumi, Osaka Prefecture, of inflicting bodily injury.

"The way she committed the crime was unprecedented, inhumane and cruel," Presiding Judge Masahiro Hosoi said as he handed down the ruling. Prosecutors had demanded an eight-year prison term.  Read More ..